Journal of Public Economics · 2022 · Jochem de Bresser、Marike G. Knoef
中文摘要
本文提出一项新的调查题项,用以衡量人们对收入再分配的偏好。受访者通过调整收入最低的四个五分位组的税率,构建自己偏好的税后收入分布。最高收入五分位组的税收会自动调整,以保持政府收入不变,同时将对税前收入的行为效应纳入考虑。来自荷兰人口的一个大型代表性样本的数据显示,以基尼系数衡量,约50%—60%的受访者构建的收入分布总体上比现状更为平等。事实上,仅有5%的受访者选择了更高的不平等程度,但其程度并未超过单一税率制下的水平。收入分布下半部分和上半部分各自的收入比率表明,人们对较高收入群体内部进一步再分配的支持,强于对较低收入群体内部进一步再分配的支持。受访者对新题项的回答能够预测近三年后议会选举中的投票行为,即使控制李克特量表后仍然如此,这为这些回答的有效性提供了支持。两项信息提供实验展示了这些新数据的丰富性。
Abstract
This paper introduces a new survey item through which to measure people’s preferences toward income redistribution. Respondents construct their preferred distribution of after-tax income by changing the tax rates of the bottom four income quintiles. Taxes for the top quintile update automatically in order to keep government revenues fixed and take into account behavioral effects on pre-tax income. Data from a large, representative sample of the Dutch population indicates that around 50–60% of the respondents construct distributions that are more equal overall than the status quo, as measured by the Gini coefficient. Indeed, only 5% of respondents opt for greater inequality, but not beyond a flat-tax. Income ratios for the bottom and top half of the distribution indicate greater support for additional redistribution among those on higher rather than lower incomes. The validity of the responses to the new item is supported by their predictive power for voting behavior in the parliamentary elections almost three years later, even when controlling for a Likert scale. Two information provision experiments illustrate the richness of the new data.