← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

攫取型殖民经济的发展效应:爪哇的荷兰强制种植制度

The Development Effects of the Extractive Colonial Economy: The Dutch Cultivation System in Java
Review of Economic Studies · 2019 · Melissa Dell、Benjamin Olken

中文摘要

殖民列强通常在殖民地组织经济活动以最大化其经济回报。尽管文献强调了通过制度质量产生的长期负面经济影响,但历史上为刺激生产而实施的经济组织变革也可能在长期直接影响经济组织,产生抵消效应。我们在荷兰强制种植制度的背景下考察了这些效应,该制度是用于生产糖的工农综合系统,构成了19世纪爪哇荷兰殖民企业的核心。我们表明,与原本同样适合建立殖民糖厂的附近反事实地点相比,靠近荷兰在19世纪中叶建立糖厂的地区如今更工业化、拥有更好的基础设施、教育水平更高且更富裕。我们还使用围绕各工厂腹地的空间断点回归设计表明,被迫种植甘蔗的村庄拥有更多的村有土地,并且在历史上和今天都拥有更多的学校和显著更高的教育水平。结果表明,殖民者为促进生产而实施的经济结构可以继续在长期促进经济活动,我们讨论了此类效应最可能发挥重要作用的情境。

Abstract

Abstract Colonial powers typically organized economic activity in the colonies to maximize their economic returns. While the literature has emphasized long-run negative economic impacts via institutional quality, the changes in economic organization implemented to spur production historically could also directly influence economic organization in the long-run, exerting countervailing effects. We examine these in the context of the Dutch Cultivation System, the integrated industrial and agricultural system for producing sugar that formed the core of the Dutch colonial enterprise in 19th century Java. We show that areas close to where the Dutch established sugar factories in the mid-19th century are today more industrialized, have better infrastructure, are more educated, and are richer than nearby counterfactual locations that would have been similarly suitable for colonial sugar factories. We also show, using a spatial regression discontinuity design on the catchment areas around each factory, that villages forced to grow sugar cane have more village-owned land and also have more schools and substantially higher education levels, both historically and today. The results suggest that the economic structures implemented by colonizers to facilitate production can continue to promote economic activity in the long run, and we discuss the contexts where such effects are most likely to be important.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →