Journal of Development Economics · 2024 · Aditi Dimri、Véronique Gille、Philipp Ketz
中文摘要
本文表明,性别选择性流产会引致生育间隔时长与下一胎子女的性别之间产生相关性。借助一个统计模型,我们表明,若下一胎为女孩时生育间隔更短,则意味着在连续生育之间发生了多次性别选择性流产。分析印度的数据,我们发现在第一胎为女孩时,第二胎次存在多次性别选择性流产的证据;而在前两胎均为女孩时,第三胎次存在强烈的证据。为量化多次流产的程度,我们提出了一个最大似然估计量,可给出实施流产的女性数量及其重复流产的可能性。我们的估计结果揭示了在胎次、同胞构成以及社会人口和地理群体之间存在显著异质性。值得注意的是,第一胎为女孩的识字女性和城市女性很少进行第二次流产,而印度北部前两胎均为女孩的女性则表现出13%的重复性别选择性流产可能性。在该群体中,估计的被流产女胎数量——性别选择性流产的标准测度——比实施流产的女性数量高出50%。• 性别选择性流产会引致生育间隔与下一胎子女性别之间的相关性。• 若下一胎为女孩时生育间隔更短,则意味着多次性别选择性流产。• 印度数据揭示了不同群体之间的显著异质性。• 第一胎为女孩的识字女性和城市女性很少进行第二次流产。• 前两胎均为女孩的北部女性中,重复流产的可能性为13%。
Abstract
This paper demonstrates that sex-selective abortion induces a correlation between birth interval length and the sex of the next-born child. Using a statistical model, we show that shorter birth intervals for next-born girls indicate repeated sex-selective abortions between consecutive births. Analyzing data from India, we find evidence of repeated sex-selective abortions at birth order 2 when the first child is a girl, and strong evidence at birth order 3 when the first two children are girls. To quantify the extent of repeated abortions, we propose a maximum likelihood estimator that provides the number of women who abort and their likelihood of performing repeated abortions. Our estimation results reveal significant heterogeneity across birth orders, sibling compositions, and socio-demographic and geographic groups. Notably, literate and urban women who first had a girl rarely abort a second time, whereas women in northern India who first had two girls show a 13% likelihood of repeated sex-selective abortion. In this group, the estimated number of aborted female fetuses—the standard measure of sex-selective abortion—is 50% higher than the number of women who abort. • Sex-selective abortions induce correlation between spacing and sex of next-born child. • Shorter spacing for next-born girls indicates repeated sex-selective abortions. • Indian data reveals significant heterogeneity across groups. • Literate and urban women who first had a girl rarely abort a second time. • 13% likelihood of repeated abortion among northern women who first had two girls.