← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

当啤酒比水更安全时:啤酒可获得性与水源性疾病死亡率

When beer is safer than water: Beer availability and mortality from waterborne illnesses
Journal of Development Economics · 2024 · Francisca Antman、James M. Flynn

中文摘要

本文考察了18世纪英国工业革命时期啤酒对死亡率的影响。由于酿造过程,在人们尚未普遍认识到水质与人类健康之间的联系之前,啤酒相对于可用水源而言是一种改善。运用多种识别策略,构建由增税、天气事件和土壤质量所驱动的啤酒稀缺性度量,我们表明啤酒稀缺性与更高的死亡率相关,特别是在夏季,此时死亡率更可能由与受污染饮用水相关的水源性疾病所引起。我们还利用各教区固有水质的差异,使用两个水质代理变量,表明在水质较差的地区,啤酒稀缺导致了更多的死亡。综合来看,证据表明,在这一经济发展的重要时期,啤酒对人类健康产生了重大影响。

Abstract

We investigate the impact of beer on mortality during the Industrial Revolution in 18th century England. Due to the brewing process, beer represented an improvement over available water sources during this period prior to the widespread understanding of the link between water quality and human health. Using a wide range of identification strategies to derive measures of beer scarcity driven by tax increases, weather events, and soil quality, we show that beer scarcity was associated with higher mortality, especially in the summer months when mortality was more likely to be driven by waterborne illnesses related to contaminated drinking water. We also leverage variation in inherent water quality across parishes using two proxies for water quality to show that beer scarcity resulted in greater deaths in areas with worse water quality. Together, the evidence indicates that beer had a major impact on human health during this important period in economic development.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →