← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

斯大林与不信任的起源

Stalin and the origins of mistrust
Journal of Public Economics · 2022 · Milena Nikolova、Ol'ga Ivanovna Popova、Vladimir Otrachshenko

中文摘要

我们表明,前苏联国家内部当前信任水平的差异可追溯至斯大林统治时期的强制监狱劳动体系,该体系以高监禁率、镇压和严厉惩罚为特征。我们认为,那些暴露于强制劳动营(古拉格)的人变得不那么信任,并将这一社会规范传递给其后代。结合当代个体层面的调查数据与关于强制劳动营位置的历史信息,我们发现,居住在原古拉格附近的个体具有较低的社会信任与制度信任水平。我们的结果对一系列敏感性检验保持稳健,这表明我们记录的关系是因果性的。我们概述了若干因果机制,并检验了古拉格附近的不信任社会规范究竟源于政治镇压,还是源于对囚犯带来犯罪的恐惧。因此,我们为历史影响当前社会经济结果的渠道提供了新证据。

Abstract

We show that current differences in trust levels within former Soviet Union countries can be traced back to the system of forced prison labor during Stalin's rule, which was marked by high incarceration rates, repression, and harsh punishments. We argue that those exposed to forced labor camps (gulags) became less trusting and transferred this social norm to their descendants. Combining contemporary individual-level survey data with historical information on the location of forced labor camps, we find that individuals who live near former gulags have low levels of social and institutional trust. Our results are robust to a battery of sensitivity checks, which suggests that the relationship we document is causal. We outline several causal mechanisms and test whether the social norm of mistrust near gulags developed because of political repression or due to fear that inmates bring criminality. As such, we provide novel evidence on the channels through which history matters for current socio-economic outcomes today.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →