← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

种族主义的累积成本与黑人赔偿的账单

The Cumulative Costs of Racism and the Bill for Black Reparations
Journal of Economic Perspectives · 2022 · William A. Jr. Darity、A. Kirsten Mullen、Marvin Slaughter

中文摘要

本文考虑了确定美国奴隶制黑人后裔赔偿计划货币价值的两种主要程序:1)列举暴行并为每项赋予美元价值,作为加总的前置步骤;以及2)识别一个概括性指标,以捕捉反黑人暴行累积的、跨代际效应的美元金额。在第一种方法即逐项列记策略下,我们评估了被奴役者因奴役而遭受的工资成本、奴隶制施害者的财务收益、内战后白人大屠杀和私刑对黑人受害者造成的损害、因联邦住房管理局和《退伍军人权利法案》在购房支持提供上的歧视所导致的损失,以及因就业中的种族歧视导致的收入惩罚。在第二种方法即全局指标策略下,我们计算了1865年向被解放奴隶提供40英亩土地的现值,以及当前美国黑人与白人之间的财富差距。我们得出结论,后一种标准,即种族财富差距,为衡量黑人赔偿账单的规模提供了最佳尺度。

Abstract

Two major procedures for establishing the monetary value of a plan for reparations for Black American descendants of US slavery are considered in this paper: 1) Enumeration of atrocities and assignment of a dollar value to each as a prelude to adding up the total, and 2) Identification of a summary measure that captures the dollar amount of the cumulative, intergenerational effects of anti-Black atrocities. Under the first approach, the itemization strategy, we assess wage costs to the enslaved of bondage; financial gains to the perpetrators of slavery; damages to Black victims of post-Civil War white massacres and lynchings; losses from discrimination in the provision of the home buying supports from the Federal Housing Administration and the G.I. Bill; and income penalties due to racial discrimination in employment. Under the second approach, the global indicator strategy, we calculate the present value of providing 40 acres of land to freed slaves in 1865 and the current wealth gap between Black and White Americans. We conclude that the latter standard, the racial wealth gap, provides the best gauge for the size of the bill for Black reparations.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →