← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

从韦伯到卡夫卡:政治不稳定与法律过度生产

From Weber to Kafka: Political Instability and the Overproduction of Laws
American Economic Review · 2021 · Gabriele Gratton、Luigi Guiso、Claudio Michelacci、Massimo Morelli

中文摘要

在低效的官僚机构下,法律的效果难以评估,无能的政治家可能通过立法来树立其作为熟练改革者的声誉。由于过多的法律会削弱官僚效率,这一机制可能产生一个卡夫卡式官僚体制的稳态。政治不稳定的暂时激增会加剧过度生产法律的激励,并可能使经济向卡夫卡式状态转移。与理论一致,在20世纪90年代初政治不稳定激增之后,意大利经历了低质量立法数量的显著增加与官僚效率的下降。(JEL D72, D73)

Abstract

With inefficient bureaucratic institutions, the effects of laws are hard to assess and incompetent politicians may pass laws to build a reputation as skillful reformers. Since too many laws curtail bureaucratic efficiency, this mechanism can generate a steady state with Kafkaesque bureaucracy. Temporary surges in political instability heighten the incentives to overproduce laws and can shift the economy towards the Kafkaesque state. Consistent with the theory, after a surge in political instability in the early 1990s, Italy experienced a significant increase in the amount of poor-quality legislation and a decrease in bureaucratic efficiency. (JEL D72, D73)
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →