← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

指望我的选票不算数:委员会中的表达性投票

Counting on my vote not counting: Expressive voting in committees
Journal of Public Economics · 2021 · Boris Ginzburg、José-Alberto Guerra、Warn N. Lekfuangfu

中文摘要

投票制度如何影响委员会成员进行表达性投票的激励?我们构建了一个委员会模型,其决定是否批准一项部分成员可能认为符合道德的提案。投票赞成该提案的成员获得表达性效用,而若提案被接受,所有成员都需承担成本。委员会成员可能具有不同的推理深度。在某些充分条件下,模型预测,降低某一成员成为关键票概率的特征——即更大的委员会规模或更严格的投票规则——会提高支持该提案的票数份额。一项以慈善捐款为框架的实验室实验提供了与这些结果一致的证据。我们的结构估计还原了个体间利他偏好与表达性偏好以及推理深度的分布。

Abstract

How do voting institutions affect incentives of committees to vote expressively? We model a committee that chooses whether to approve a proposal that some members may consider ethical. Members who vote for the proposal receive expressive utility, and all members pay a cost if the proposal is accepted. Committee members may have different depths of reasoning. Under certain sufficient conditions, the model predicts that features that reduce the probability of a member being pivotal – namely, larger committee size, or a more restrictive voting rule – raise the share of votes in favour of the proposal. A laboratory experiment with a charitable donation framing presents evidence in line with these results. Our structural estimation recovers the distributions of altruistic and expressive preferences, as well as of depth of reasoning, across individuals.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →