← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

聪明才酷还是酷才聪明?理解教育中的同伴压力

Cool to be Smart or Smart to be Cool? Understanding Peer Pressure in Education
Review of Economic Studies · 2018 · Leonardo Bursztyn、Georgy Egorov、Robert Jensen

中文摘要

我们构建并检验了两种基于学校的同伴文化:一种将努力污名化,另一种对能力给予奖励。模型表明,当同伴能够观察到参与情况和表现时,上述任何一种文化均可能减少对教育活动的参与。我们设计了一项实地实验,使我们能够检验并区分这两种关注点。我们发现,在两个截然不同的高中环境中,同伴压力对SAT备考套餐领取的减少作用几乎完全相同。然而,这些效应产生于截然不同的机制:一种环境中是出于隐藏努力的愿望,而另一种环境中是出于隐藏低能力的愿望。

Abstract

Abstract We model and test two school-based peer cultures: one that stigmatizes effort and one that rewards ability. The model shows that either may reduce participation in educational activities when peers can observe participation and performance. We design a field experiment that allows us to test for, and differentiate between, these two concerns. We find that peer pressure reduces takeup of an SAT prep package virtually identically across two very different high school settings. However, the effects arise from very distinct mechanisms: a desire to hide effort in one setting and a desire to hide low ability in the other.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →