← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

民粹主义下的官僚

Bureaucrats under Populism
Journal of Public Economics · 2021 · Greg Sasso、Massimo Morelli

中文摘要

我们通过分析政治家与官僚之间的委托决策制定模型,探讨民粹主义对官僚激励的后果。民粹主义政治家偏好实施其政策承诺的官僚,而非民粹主义政治家则偏好拥有自由裁量权的好官僚。因此,民粹主义政治家的存在决定了用坏官僚替代好官僚,并激励好官僚“假装忠诚”。我们表明,当未来民粹主义执政的概率较高且官僚的潜在替代者储备较差时,假装忠诚更为普遍。我们还表明,当官僚体系强有力时,民粹主义者治下的官僚更替率更高;当官僚体系软弱时,非民粹主义者治下的官僚更替率更高。

Abstract

We explore the consequences of populism for bureaucrats’ incentives by analyzing a model of delegated policymaking between politicians and bureaucrats. Populist politicians prefer a bureaucrat who implements their policy commitment, while non-populist politicians prefer a good bureaucrat with discretion. The presence of populist politicians thus determines replacement of good with bad bureaucrats and creates incentives for good bureaucrats to “feign loyalty”. We show that feigning loyalty is more prevalent when the probability of populist leadership in the future is higher and the bureaucrats’ pool of potential replacements is worse. We also show that bureaucratic turnover is higher under populists when the bureaucracy is strong and higher under non-populists when the bureaucracy is weak.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →