← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

捆绑基因与金融技术以提升非洲小规模农户的韧性与生产率

Bundling Genetic and Financial Technologies for More Resilient and Productive Small-Scale Farmers in Africa
The Economic Journal · 2024 · Stephen R. Boucher、Michael R. Carter、Jon Einar Flatnes、Travis J. Lybbert、Jonathan Malacarne、Paswel Marenya

中文摘要

本文利用一项跨越两个非洲国家、多年且空间上多样化的随机对照试验,探讨了由基因与金融技术构成的互补捆绑是否能提升小规模农户的韧性与生产率。分析表明,中度干旱和更严重的产量损失均会削弱对照组家庭的韧性,且这些冲击具有持久影响,因为农户在遭受冲击后的投资与生产均会减少。严重的产量冲击还会加剧饥饿与粮食不安全。基因技术——耐旱种子——提供了经济上显著的保护以抵御季中干旱,并缓解了在对照组中观察到的农场生产率的长期下降。金融技术——基于卫星的指数保险——抵消了耐旱种子未能缓解的严重产量损失的长期后果。最后,分析表明,经历过冲击并见证了技术起作用的处理组农户随后将其农业投资增加至冲击前水平之上,我们将此效应称为韧性红利。遗憾的是,这种明显的经验学习具有两面性。未经历过风险管理技术功效的农户不再使用这些技术。因此,我们的研究结果展示了基因与金融风险缓解技术如何能为农户提供更完备的保护,以及诱导持续采用那些介于经验品与信任品之间且极少显露其收益的技术所面临的挑战。

Abstract

Abstract Using a multi-year, spatially diversified randomised controlled trial spanning two African countries, this paper explores whether a complementary bundle of genetic and financial technologies can boost the resilience and productivity of small-scale farmers. The analysis shows that both moderate droughts and more severe yield losses undermine the resilience of control-group households, and that these shocks have long-lasting effects as farmers invest and produce less following shocks. Severe yield shocks also increase hunger and food insecurity. The genetic technology—drought-tolerant seeds—provides economically significant protection against mid-season drought and mitigates the long-term drop in farm productivity seen in the control group. The financial technology—satellite-based index insurance—offsets the long-term consequences of severe yield losses that are not mitigated by the drought-tolerant seeds. Finally, the analysis shows that treatment-group farmers who experienced shocks and saw the technologies in action subsequently increased their agricultural investment beyond pre-shock levels, an effect we call the resilience dividend. Unfortunately, this apparent experiential learning cuts both ways. Farmers who did not experience the efficacy of the risk management technologies backed away from using them. Our findings thus showcase how genetic and financial risk-mitigating technologies can offer farmers more complete protection, as well as the challenge of inducing sustained uptake of technologies that are midway between experience and credence goods and only infrequently reveal their benefits.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →