Journal of Development Economics · 2024 · Brooke Kelsey Jack、Seema Jayachandran、Flavio Malagutti、Sarojini Rao
中文摘要
家庭的用水行为除了产生负的环境外部性之外,还伴随着另一种“市场失灵”:家庭成员相互搭便车并过度消费。该问题的根源在于消费按家庭层级计费,且家庭成员之间难以相互监督彼此的消费。我们结合公用事业账单记录与随机的个人专属价格变动,记录了这一现象在赞比亚城市地区的重要性。我们推导并实证验证了如下预测:在家庭财务安排下保护水资源的激励较弱的个体,当其个人专属价格上升时,其用水量下降得更多。另一个预测是,当较低公用事业账单所带来的财务收益在家庭成员之间分配不均时,这种过度消费问题更为严重。我们表明,当家庭的财务安排更为平等时,家庭确实似乎对家庭层级水价的变化更为敏感。我们的结果为居民用水(及用电)消费价格敏感度偏低这一现象提供了一种新的解释。
Abstract
In addition to generating a negative environmental externality, a household’s water consumption entails another “market failure”: household members free-ride off each other and overconsume. The problem stems from consumption being billed at the household level and the difficulty of monitoring one another’s consumption. We document the importance of this phenomenon in urban Zambia by combining utility billing records and randomized person-specific price variation. We derive and empirically confirm the following prediction: Individuals with weaker incentives to conserve under the household’s financial arrangements reduce water use more when their person-specific price increases. Another prediction is that this overconsumption problem is more acute when the financial benefit of a lower utility bill is shared unevenly among household members. We show that households indeed seem more responsive to a change in the household-level price of water when their financial arrangements are more equal. Our results offer a novel explanation for the low price sensitivity of residential water (and electricity) consumption.