← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

注意力不足至关重要:消费者在选择水价方案时不作为的分析

Inattention Matters: An Analysis of Consumers’ Inaction in Choosing a Water Tariff
Journal of the European Economic Association · 2023 · Florian Heiß、Carmine Ornaghi、Mirco Tonin

中文摘要

本文研究消费者在两种不同水价方案之间的选择。我们在一个新颖的情境中记录了大量不作为现象:客户面临二元决策,并获得关于若转换水价方案可获得的费用节省的简单、详细且个性化的信息。我们的实证框架区分了惯性的两个来源:注意力不足与转换成本。模型估计,在能从更换水价方案中获益的客户中,有一半并未意识到自己所获得的机会。在予以关注的条件下,我们估计转换成本中位数约为100英镑。相反,假设所有客户均予以关注的模型会得出高得不合实际的转换成本,中位数为400英镑。这表明注意力不足在解释消费者不作为方面的重要性。考察家庭特征,我们的结果证实了以往发现:家庭受教育水平较高或少数族裔比例较低的地区对潜在节省表现出更高的反应性。我们的分析提供的新洞见是,这一差异完全由注意力驱动,而转换成本实际上随教育水平和族群同质性的提高而上升。我们的研究结果表明,旨在提高注意力的政策可以在促进供应商之间的竞争和减少不平等方面发挥核心作用。

Abstract

Abstract This paper studies consumers’ choice between two different water tariffs. We document a large inaction in a novel setting where customers face a binary decision and receive simple, detailed, and personalized information about the financial savings they would obtain if they were to switch water tariff. Our empirical framework separates two sources of inertia: inattention and switching costs. The model estimates that half of the customers that would benefit from changing tariff are not aware of the opportunity they are offered. Conditional on paying attention, we estimate median switching costs to be around £100. A model where all customers are assumed to pay attention delivers instead implausibly high switching costs, with a median of £400. This shows the importance of inattention in explaining consumers’ inaction. Looking at the characteristics of the households, our results confirm previous findings that areas where households have higher levels of education or the proportion of minorities is lower display a higher responsiveness to potential savings. The new insight offered by our analysis is that this is entirely driven by attention, whereas switching costs actually increase with education and ethnic homogeneity. Our findings suggest that policies aimed at increasing attention can play a central role in fostering competition among suppliers and reducing inequalities.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →