← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

广泛类别资格政策与SNAP参与

Broad‐Based Categorical Eligibility Policy and SNAP Participation
Journal of Policy Analysis and Management · 2026 · Xingguo Wang、Pourya Valizadeh、Rodolfo M. Nayga、Henry L. Bryant、Bart L. Fischer

中文摘要

广泛类别资格(broad-based categorical eligibility, BBCE)政策允许各州在确定补充营养援助计划(SNAP)资格时绕开联邦总收入与资产审查。政策制定者经常提议限制BBCE的适用范围或将其彻底取消。然而,我们对BBCE影响SNAP参与的理解一直仅依赖静态双向固定效应(TWFE)估计量,而这类估计量因假设处理效应在各州之间和不同时期不存在异质性而受到批评。在本研究中,我们使用对异质性稳健的双重差分估计量,给出了BBCE影响的新估计,其数值是静态TWFE模型所得估计的两倍以上。重要的是,我们的事件研究分析表明,在按采纳时点划分的各州群体中,BBCE的效应随时间一致增大,这解释了静态TWFE模型所估计出的较小效应。此外,我们发现,尽管BBCE将资格扩展至收入较高的家庭,但其对参与的大部分影响发生在依据联邦总收入限额原本已具备资格的家庭中。我们的反事实模拟进一步表明,2000年至2016年间,将资格扩展至较高收入家庭约占BBCE所致参与增量的11.5%和项目支出增量的3.8%,其余部分则由原本在收入上已具资格的家庭所驱动。

Abstract

ABSTRACT The broad‐based categorical eligibility (BBCE) policy allows states to bypass federal gross income and asset tests for supplemental nutrition assistance program (SNAP) eligibility. Policymakers often propose limiting BBCE's scope or eliminating it altogether. Yet, our understanding of BBCE's impact on SNAP participation has relied solely on static two‐way fixed effects (TWFE) estimators, which have been criticized for assuming no treatment effect heterogeneity across states and over time. In this study, using a heterogeneity‐robust difference‐in‐differences estimator, we provide new estimates of BBCE's impact that are more than twice as large as those derived from the static TWFE models. Importantly, our event‐study analysis shows that BBCE's effect has increased uniformly over time across state groups defined by their adoption timing, explaining the smaller effects estimated by the static TWFE model. In addition, we find that although BBCE extended eligibility to higher‐income households, most of its impact on participation occurred among households already eligible under federal gross income limits. Our counterfactual simulations further show that between 2000 and 2016, extending eligibility to higher‐income households accounted for approximately 11.5% of the increase in participation and 3.8% of the rise in program spending resulting from BBCE, with the remainder driven by already income‐eligible households.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →